| FLOODING - The Rivers Agency recommendations |
| In a letter to the Planning Case Office on
7 May 2002 (in response to the second amended plan) we made the following
observation:- |
| 7 May 2002
"With the recent unveiling
of the "Climate
Change Study", a Government funded research document, Northern
Ireland Environment Minister Dermot Nesbitt commented that researchers
had found there is a low public awareness and concern about climate
change and its impact.
Flooding is one of the impacts that we are
very aware of, yet we were told when visiting your Planning Department
in April that the Planning Service "Has no policy
on global warming and flooding" ….. Surely
the authorities including the Northern Ireland Planning Service
cannot ignore media
coverage in recent years of the severe flooding problems elsewhere
in the UK?" |
|
| |
| Acceptance. Here is an extract from the "acceptance" letter written
on 18th November 2003 to the Planners by an official of the Rivers Agency |
|
18 Nov. 2003 "
1. A designated watercourse
known to us as the Distillery Burn affects the above site and photographic
evidence
shows that the low-lying parts of the site adjacent to this watercourse
are prone to flooding.
2. Rivers Agency advises Planning Service against
permitting development in floodplains or the in-filling of floodplains
to facilitate development. Consequently development of this site
should be restricted to that part of the site, which lies above
the 100-year flood level. This is estimated to be 22.67m OD at
the downstream
end of the site, 23.87m OD at the spillway and 23.90m OD at the
upstream end of the site. A suitable freeboard is normally added
to this level
for design purposes. The site layout plan (Drg. No. 02/55:02)
submitted to Planning Service on 28 May 2003 would therefore be
acceptable. (This emphasis of the sentence was on
the original Rivers letter)
3. It should be noted that (the) .......Distillery
extracts water from the Distillery Burn and any
outfalls from the development should be downstream of the extraction
point
at the spillway."
|
|
| "Freeboard" mentioned in the above letter, is an
extra area on the flood plain boundary in addition to the recommended "No
Build and no Infill" area. This freeboard enlarges the sloping sides
of the 100 year flood level. A member of the Rivers Agency Operations Support
Unit
defined
'freeboard'
as :- "A technical
term, and in this context, it is the vertical distance or height above
a design
level to allow for fluctuations in the water surface
caused by, for example, wave action." |
| |
| A 100 year flood plain (referred to as Q100) is a "prophesy" by
the Rivers Agency which has defined an area they calculate will flood at
least
once in a hundred years. It could flood more often than that
but once in a hundred years is enough to merit being put in that category.
The Rivers Agency even included a large-scale plan of the development area
with the flood plain marked in blue.
This plan
is available for you to see
here
at
No. 32 |
| |
On 10 Feb 2004 we visited the Area Engineer
for the Rivers Agency and took with us the May 2003 cross section plans
of the proposed developments which accompanied the "acceptable" drawing
02/55:02 and the Engineer was
able
to calculate for us just how much encroachment there was into the 100
year flood plain. It appears the Chartered Engineers for the Developer
are proposing to raise the ground in that flooding area by about 2 metres,
and to build the road on top of that. Parts of some of the houses will
also be on the edge of this flooding area. Is the technical jargon for
this
operation .. "in-filling
of floodplains to facilitate development". ?
(See letter above in white box) |
| |
| For copyright reasons I can't show you any plans or layouts,
so have taken information from several of them to come up with these cross
sections
to
give you an
idea
of the amount of infilling proposed. Infilling which has been
accepted by Rivers Agency. Infilling across valuable wetland. |
Here is a scaled cross section
of the site at the end nearest the caravan site. I have drawn it
in flood. The arrow
marks the 23.9
OD. You will note in the above letter that development should
be restricted to that part of the site which lies above that level.
i.e. nothing
between the arrow and the stream. Wee blob on the left is a shepherd
with a sheep for scale. Yes I know they are standing in water
but I was running out of paper
on that side! The stream in normal conditions lies in the dip below
the shepherd.

Now follows the same scaled cross section but this time showing
the extent of the proposed infilling and the position of one of the
houses. That's a wall at the top of the embankment near the stream,
presumably to stop vehicles falling into the flood water. And the
dip between the wall and the house is a road.

|
| |
And here's another cross section. Still in the upper
field but this time nearer the Straid Road. Once again a scale-drawing
of the site
in flood with the same shepherd and again the arrow marks the boundary
of the 100 year flood plain and which, according to the letter to
the Planners, the Rivers Agency say there should be no infilling
or building
between that arrow and the stream. 
Now follows the same scaled area but this time showing the proposed
infilling and building.

|
|
| |
| And our Rivers Agency engineer also calculated
for us that this artificial embankment (May 2003 Plan) would encroach in
one place over 28m into this flooding area, coming within 4 metres of the
stream bank. (In a subsequent letter to us (15/4/04) the
Director of Operations, Rivers Agency, describes the above infilling as
"small" and "insignificant") The same engineer explained flood water, squeezed into a smaller
area
by
in-filling,
would
back-up
upstream. |
| During our visit, the engineer was also able to confirm our
suspicions that the May 2003 Site Layout Plan ( Drg 02/55:02) submitted
to the Planners, would put parts of numbers 46, 47,
48 and 49 all within the flood plain area defined by the Rivers Agency. |
| |
| We wrote (16/2/04) to the Chief Executive of
the Rivers Agency asking him why their policy on building and in-filling
on
a flood
plain is not put into practice ending with the following observation:- |
16/2/2004
"Our conversation on 10th Feb
2003 with .... (the Area Engineer), pointed up the differences
between the stated principles/stance of Rivers Agency and what
is actually acceptable. Interesting in this case, with the calculations
he made for us during our meeting, one can actually see, mathematically,
by how much Rivers Agency sticks to their principles".
|
We have now had a reply. This is on a separate page and I suggest you
read on down to the bottom of this page before clicking for
the Rivers Agency reply (Yes I know it's a shambles trying to find
your way around
this
web site but so many elements are intertwined.) |
|
So Rivers Agency say no infilling or development should
take place within the Q100 area which they define very precisely, then
in the
same paragraph accepts infilling and development within that very same
proscribed area. So we queried this contradiction with the Divisional
Planning Manager who replied ...
13 Dec.2004
"
This was an informative and “people
buying a dwelling and their solicitors will wish to satisfy themselves
that the prescribed levels have been adhered to”.
DIVISIONAL PLANNING MANAGER |
So there we have it. It's not the fault of the Planners who approve
plans which allow development on a flood plain, but it's up to solicitors
to satisfy themselves that "levels have been adhered to" |
| |
| Some background information. Whilst talking on the phone
(7/5/02) to a member of the Rivers Agency we were told that if
a developer goes ahead and builds in a flood plain the Rivers Agency cannot
stop them, only advise. Surely the law needs to be changed
to rectify this |
|
| Maintenance. The Rivers Agency also recommend several
"Planning Informatives" should be included in any planning decisions including
this one :- |
"Where a Designated
Watercourse flows through or adjacent to a development site,
it is considered essential that
a working strip of minimum width 5m is left along
the bank in order to facilitate future maintenance of the watercourse
by the Rivers Agency. Actual requirement should be determined in
consultation with the Agency." |
|
| St Columb's Rill is a "Designated Watercourse" |
| << Return to list of "Flooding" pages |
|
| << Return to first page
of this Eagry web site, |