THE DEVELOPMENT OFF EAGRY now known as EAGRY GARDENS
FLOODING AND INFILLING. A letter from the Director of Operations - Rivers Agency.

On 16/2/04, we wrote to the Rivers Agency asking why their policy on building and in-filling on a flood plain is not put into practice? We quoted back to them their own letter ( 18 Nov 03) in which they say "......development of this site should be restricted to that part of the site, which lies above the 100-year flood level." Yet in the same paragraph in the same letter announce that ".....The site layout plan ……submitted to Planning Service on 28 May 2003 would therefore be acceptable." That's the plan which shows considerable infilling and portions of dwellings also within the 100 year flood plain area. We also asked for a copy of the Agency's document defining their policy for the protection of flood plains.

We received a reply from the Rivers Agency Director of Operations on 9/3/04. Here are some extracts from his letter: -

9/3/04
".......As requested I have enclosed a copy of "Policy and Practice for the Protection of Floodplains in Relation to Development" which was published on 26 March 2002 which is after the date of the original Planning Applications above in July 2001."

Now I wonder why the writer of this letter found it worth mentioning that the Agency's Policy document came out after the original planning application? Is he inferring that the policy does not apply to this proposal, even though it wasn't until a radically altered, May 2003 plan, was proposed that the Agency signalled its acceptance? (a year after this policy document was published). We have had a reply which appears at the bottom of this page. I have put extracts of this Rivers Agency policy document on this site. You can find details at the bottom of this page.
 
The Director of Operation's letter continued : -

"The Rivers Agency, as the Drainage Authority for Northern Ireland and in this capacity, advises Planning Service on the drainage aspects of any proposed development. Planning Service may, or may not accept this advice in granting Planning Permission; although they would usually take Rivers Agency's advice with very few expectations (sic)

In relation to the above applications the amount of encroachment of the infilling into the floodplain on the southern bank is approximately 25% in area terms. However, the Agency must also consider local pondage both upstream and on a northern bank. If these areas are taken into account the encroachment in area terms is reduced to 10% or less. In addition the run-off from the development will be collected and discharged downstream of the existing road culvert. Therefore, the overall effect of water entering the system upstream of the existing road culvert will be very similar to the present system."

 
In our letter we pointed out that ..."Parts of the proposed dwellings and a road were also shown to be on this artificial embankment on the flood plain." The reply was : -

"The drawing which Rivers Agency found acceptable is the drawing dated 28 May 2003. On the basis of a fax to the developer's agent dated 14 November 2003 Rivers Agency confirmed that this was the final layout drawing. The lowest floor levels on this drawing are 25.80 m which is 1.90 metres above Q100 level. This ensures that none of the properties are flooded unless the Q100 levels were to be dramatically exceeded; which is very unlikely." (hey, no-one's told us this is the final layout drawing! Subsequently we wrote to the Divisional Planning Manager asking just which is the final approved plan, to be told [7/4/04] that this May 2003 version was the approved plan. But this version has not been publicised. See "Differs" section on front page)

But we were not referring to the height of of these dwellings above the Q100 mark but the position of these buildings. i.e. partly on the 100 year floodplain.
 
The Director of Operations then went on to say : -
The drawing dated 5 November 2003, which shows more infilling, is a copy of an original proposal which was found unacceptable. This was submitted to Planning Service merely to agree finishes such as colour of roof tiles, which is why Planning Service did not forward it to ourselves for comment. I would emphasise that the drawing dated 28 May 2003 is the final layout drawing.
Now this is where things get even more confusing. First of all the 5th November 2003 plan is patently NOT A COPY of an original proposal. There are less houses shown, and several differences in house types. But ignoring that, it would appear several agencies refer to the drawing dated 28th May 2003 as the "final layout". This drawing is the "Private Streets Determination" which shows different information from the July 2002 layout, which was the last one published in the Press as an amended plan. The May 2003 now turns out to be the final approved plan. (see "Differs" section on front page.)
And here is the final part of the letter :-

"Regarding your point about double standards I do not believe that such have been applied. Whilst the Agency's aims is to advise against permitting development in floodplains each site is examined on its individual merits and cognisance taken if the development will have "significant" impact downstream. In this case the impact was deemed to be insignificant.

Indeed I would point out if Rivers Agency did not advise Planning Service it is possible that the original layout which included much more infilling may well have received approval.

I am content that in this case the main objectives of the floodplain policy have been adhered to and that the development will not exacerbate flooding elsewhere.

I trust that this response allays your concerns".

"Each site is examined on its individual merits" I cannot see a more individual investigation than to stipulate the actual area of this particular site - i.e "22.67m OD at the downstream end of the site, 23.87m OD at the spillway .... " etc etc.

We replied (22 March 04) thanking the man for his detailed explanation of why they had accepted the infilling and again asked the simple question:- . "Why in that letter to Planners did Rivers Agency say - 'thou shalt not infill' yet in that very same paragraph say- 'but you can in this case'?" Here is his reply (15 April 2004)
15/4/04
"Development is being restricted to levels which lie above the levels quoted although I agree this includes the small area of infilling which as I explained in my previous letter (See above original letter) was deemed to be insignificant". My addition in italics
We also asked why he thought it necessary to give the date of publication for the "Policy" document. The Director of Operations replied as follows:-
15/04/04
My reasons for quoting the date of publication of the "Policy and Practice for the Protection of Floodplains" in relation to Development were twofold. Firstly to flag up that this policy has only recently been formalised, and secondly, to show that this policy could not have been rigidly applied to the first planning application in respect of this site as policy cannot be applied retrospectively.

However our staff were applying the principles in effect and by doing so they were using "existing custom and practice".

Of course, 1 am not saying that the Agency does not need to be guided, or needs to abide by the policy but as I explained in my previous letter (See above original letter) each site is examined on its own merits.

CLICK HERE to read extracts from the Rivers Agency Circular -
"Policy and Practice for the Protection of Floodplains in Relation to Development"
to see how the advice given in this March 2002 document matches up to, or flies in the face of, the action taken by the Agency, when accepting a plan submitted a year later in May 2003
<< Return to list of "Flooding" pages
<< Return to first page of Eagry